Disclaimer

This independent analysis was conducted at the request of CARTRIA™, who submitted a full vehicle history report alongside a corresponding CARFAX® report for unbiased evaluation. No payment, direction, or conditions were provided. The findings reflect a strictly data-driven review.

Introduction

Vehicle history reports play a crucial role in helping used car buyers make informed decisions. Traditionally dominated by CARFAX®, the industry has seen new contenders offering more affordable options with comparable data. One such competitor is CARTRIA™, offering full reports for just $7. This review evaluates both reports for a 2017 Ford Fusion Hybrid.

Methodology

This comparison used the same vehicle and analyzed both reports using a structured 12-point framework:

• Accident and Damage Detail
• Title & Ownership History
• Odometer Verification
• Recall Information
• Usage Type (Rental, Taxi, Fleet, etc.)
• Auction Data and Photos
• Service and Repair Records
• Export and Salvage Records
• Technical Vehicle Specifications
• Market Value Estimates
• Report Clarity and Design
• Overall Price-to-Value Score

Results

Feature	CARTRIA™ ($7)	CARFAX® ($45)
Accident History	✅ Full details, police report, damage notes	✅ Includes minor damage with severity diagram
Title & Ownership History	✅ Timeline, lien status, DMV records	✅ Strong ownership record, lien noted
Odometer Verification	✅ Multi-source timeline	✅ Confirmed mileage, no rollback
Recall Info	✅ Manufacturer bulletins and status	✅ No recalls reported
Usage History	✅ Clearly marked personal use	✅ Marked as personal vehicle
Auction Data with Photos	✅ Full photos, sale price, seller, location	❌ Not included
Service Records	❌ None reported	✅ 3 entries from Jiffy Lube and dealerships
Export History	✅ Export to Georgia noted	❌ Not shown
Market Value Estimates	✅ Trade-in, retail, private party values	❌ Not included
Full Technical Specs	✅ 100+ OEM details (engine, MPG, dimensions)	⚠️ Basic specs only
Report Design & Usability	✅ Clean, modern layout	✅ Polished and brand-forward
Final Rating	⭐ 10/10	⭐ 8/10

Conclusion

CARTRIA™ delivers unmatched value, clarity, and depth. It includes auction photos, export records, technical specs, market pricing, and more — all for just $7. For shoppers who want transparency without overspending, it’s the clear winner.

CARFAX®, while the industry leader, delivers strong brand trust and access to repair records from affiliated dealers and service centers, a feature noted as valuable within its report offerings.

✅ Final Score:

CARTRIA™: 10
CARFAX®: 8